In our previous segment, we discussed how to begin your search for the right attorney—looking at online reviews, doing your research, and narrowing down your options. Now, let’s talk about what happens once you’re ready to speak with a lawyer, whether over the phone or, ideally, in person.
Why Meeting Your Lawyer Matters?
We strongly recommend meeting with any potential attorney face-to-face. If that’s not possible, at least have a personal phone or video conversation. This is your opportunity to get to know the person who could be representing you in what may be one of the most important legal matters of your life.
If you’ve been seriously injured in a car accident, suffered from a medical misdiagnosis, or your family has been affected by someone else’s negligence, choosing the right legal representation is crucial. These cases are often life-changing and highly emotional, so you need to feel confident and comfortable with your lawyer.
Questions to Ask – and Red Flags to Watch For
During your first meeting, you’ll have a chance to ask questions and hear how the attorney answers them. You want someone who listens carefully, explains things clearly, and doesn’t pressure you into signing anything right away.
One major red flag to watch for: If a lawyer guarantees you a specific amount of money in your first conversation—walk away. No ethical or experienced New York personal injury attorney can promise you a specific settlement or verdict amount upfront. Why? Because there are too many variables involved:
- The extent of the injury and whether the victim will fully recover
- The medical records and documentation available
- The victim’s past and future lost wages or earning capacity
- Whether ongoing medical treatment is necessary
- How well the injured person presents as a witness
- The identity and credibility of the defendant(s)
- The county (jurisdiction) where the case will be heard (some New York counties are more plaintiff-friendly than others)
- The insurance company involved
- And many more factors
These details are discovered over time, as your lawyer investigates, gathers evidence, and communicates with experts. Throughout the case, a skilled attorney will discuss the potential value of your claim, but making promises during the first conversation is not only unrealistic—it’s misleading.
What’s Next?
We’ll talk about which specific questions to ask during that initial consultation, so you can make an informed decision and feel empowered throughout the legal process.
If you’re looking for a personal injury or medical malpractice attorney in New York, stay tuned and make sure to explore the rest of our educational series.